Proposed laws geared toward defending South Dakota farmers from potential “agro-terrorism” actions might have a secondary impact of limiting entry to some details about the state’s largest animal feeding operations.
Senate Bill 14 seeks to strengthen a set of current legal guidelines that make it against the law for anybody to steal livestock, launch animals, trespass on farms or intervene with farm operations.
As written, the invoice additionally would add felony penalties for utilizing deception to enter or achieve employment at an agricultural operation or to make use of cameras or different surveillance strategies to spy on a farm or agricultural analysis facility. The invoice additionally would make it against the law to intervene with or destroy crops or buildings at farms and agricultural analysis amenities.
“Basically, it’s a property safety, property rights invoice for farmers and ranchers,” the invoice’s lead sponsor, Sen. Casey Crabtree (R-Madison), informed Information Watch.
The measure, Crabtree stated, is just like legal guidelines handed over roughly the previous 15 years in Iowa that sought to forestall animal-rights activists or anybody else from getting into or recording actions at farms as a way to discover proof of attainable animal mistreatment or abuse.
Dubbed “ag-gag” legal guidelines by opponents, the legal guidelines have been challenged in court docket on First Modification grounds. Regardless of some decrease court docket rulings, the Iowa legal guidelines most just like Crabtree’s proposal have been upheld as constitutional by a federal appeals court docket in 2024.
Crabtree stated he hasn’t heard of widespread efforts to infiltrate or intervene with South Dakota farm operations, however a mink farm in Arlington has skilled issues previously.
Operators of that farm didn’t return a name looking for remark.
The intent of the invoice is to cease “unhealthy actors” from utilizing deception or expertise to probably paint an unfair image of what’s occurring on South Dakota farms, Crabtree stated.
“We’ve acquired reviews again about environmentalist teams which might be attacking manufacturing amenities, or that they is likely to be utilizing drones and cameras, is basically the place this comes from,” he stated.
Ag teams push for Senate Invoice 14
The drafting of SB 14 was aided by a lot of farm teams that gathered final summer season to establish methods to assist agricultural producers within the 2025 legislative session, stated Matthew Bogue, public coverage director for the South Dakota Farm Bureau Federation.
South Dakota farmers deserve safety from anybody who might have “intent to trigger bodily or financial hurt” to a farmer or farm operation, he stated.
State farm teams have heard issues from producers that folks might break into their farms or trespass with in poor health intent, Bogue stated.
“It’s by no means a nasty time to be proactive,” he stated. “In our opinion, this modernizes the prevailing statutes.”
Invoice would restrict info on CAFOs
However the invoice additionally would add a brand new part to state legislation that might make it tougher for the general public, the press and even native governments from acquiring details about the state’s largest animal operations.
Concentrated animal feeding operations, or CAFOs, are massive livestock operations the place a number of hundred and even tens of 1000’s of cattle, hogs, chickens and turkeys are fed inside a single farm, usually in enclosed buildings.
CAFOs are closely regulated in South Dakota, and operators should acquire a allow and endure inspection of their operations and their data to make sure correct waste administration and safety of water sources.
Part 6 in SB 14 would bar the state Division of Agriculture and Pure Sources – which oversees CAFO allowing and inspection – from releasing an inventory of permitted CAFOs and their areas in South Dakota to anybody until required by federal legislation.
The invoice additionally would supply DANR discretion on whether or not to launch an inventory of CAFOs to any “South Dakota state company or native authorities for info relating to a permitted operation within the jurisdiction of the company or native authorities.”
Data may very well be obtained in individual
Crabtree stated a person or authorities entity might nonetheless acquire an inventory of CAFOs and their areas by making an in-person request on the places of work of DANR in Pierre.
The restriction on acquiring details about CAFOs worries Jay Gilbertson, supervisor of the East Dakota Water Growth District, which promotes conservation and administration of water sources in jap South Dakota.
The explanation CAFOs are permitted within the first place is to take care of oversight of their operations and to permit for the state and others to make sure the big farms aren’t polluting the land and water, he stated.
Limiting public entry to CAFO permits might make it extra doubtless that giant livestock operators would reduce corners or keep away from costly waste administration or water safety techniques with out anybody realizing, Gilbertson stated.
“The permits are fairly express and include all types of issues ‘thou shall or shan’t do,’ which makes it straightforward to stick to as a result of the operator is aware of precisely what is predicted,” he stated.
“On the similar time, if I’m any individual who is worried a few facility, I can take a look at the allow necessities and it’ll inform me, ‘That is precisely what is meant to be happening.’ And whether it is, superb. But when it isn’t, there isn’t any debate that there’s an issue.”
CAFOs increasing in South Dakota
State officers stated CAFOs are typically nicely operated and observe state legal guidelines. However issues do happen and fines have been levied in opposition to allow violators.
In keeping with prior research by Information Watch, permitted CAFOs in South Dakota violated state laws 217 instances from October 2009 to August 2019. The state acquired, on common, about two complaints about CAFOS from the general public every month, and animal wastes from CAFOs leaked into state waterways on 9 events throughout that point interval, based on state data.
The variety of animals raised and fed in CAFOs has elevated steadily over the previous decade.
The state and lawmakers have taken steps in recent times to make it simpler for improvement of CAFOs and tougher for residents and native governments to combat them. The state additionally has offered financial incentives to livestock producers to expedite improvement of recent CAFO operations.
Brian Walsh, deputy secretary of DANR, wrote in an electronic mail to Information Watch that the division already denies launch of CAFO info to some who request it.
“DANR critiques and considers every particular person request for info on Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations (CAFOs) as they’re submitted. DANR has acquired requests for an aggregated itemizing of all CAFOs together with particular location info (addresses, geographic coordinate techniques areas, or authorized areas) with the specific goal of sharing these areas on-line,” Walsh wrote. “DANR has denied such requests previously as a result of problem of biosecurity and agro-terrorism dangers. The invoice as drafted wouldn’t change how DANR at present responds to requests for CAFO data requests.”
However Gilbertson stated it appears odd that language within the invoice might forestall the general public or native governments from realizing the place CAFOs are situated.
“The division (DANR) has the instruments to permit folks to look issues up for all of the permits they problem,” he stated. “However in the case of animal feeding operations, in the event you actually need to know, you must go to Pierre, and attempt to get within the DANR constructing and dig by way of the paper information? That may simply be foolish.”
___
This story was initially revealed by South Dakota News Watch and distributed by way of a partnership with The Related Press.
Copyright 2025 Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials is probably not revealed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Subjects
Agribusiness
