A Virginia pupil assistant who suffered accidents in each knees after being kicked 25 instances over a interval of 11 days just isn’t entitled to employees’ compensation advantages.
The Virginia Staff’ Compensation Fee (WCC) upheld a deputy commissioner’s denial of advantages as a result of, consistent with the state’s employees compensation legislation, an harm that is because of cumulative trauma, and which didn’t stem from an identifiable incident, just isn’t compensable as a office harm accidentally.
The claimant, a conduct assistant for the Loudoun County Public Faculties, filed a declare on July 18, 2022 alleging that he sustained a compensable harm accidentally to each knees on September 30, 2021. At his advantages listening to, the assistant testified that every day over an 11-day interval previous to September 30, 2021, a pupil kicked him in his knees, and attacked him and his co-workers. He estimated being kicked 20 to 25 instances. He sought medical therapy on February 27, 2023. His physician identified “prepatellar bursitis each knees” resulting from “kicked in each knees repeatedly by pupil.”
The college system objected to his employees compensation declare on the bottom that he didn’t undergo a sudden, structural bodily change resulting from an identifiable incident as required underneath Virginia legislation. Final September, a deputy commissioner denied the declare.
The assistant admitted that his bilateral knee harm was not sudden however occurred over time and was not the results of one identifiable occasion.
The report was constant along with his admission. The primary report of harm on April 29, 2022 exhibits that “over the course of the week in September the claimant was kicked roughly 25 instances.” Throughout a recorded interview with the declare administrator on July 13, 2022, the claimant defined, “It’s 11 days straight so it wasn’t simply that occasion that specific day.” Additionally, the claimant’s declare type filed July 18, 2022 comprises the next description of how the harm occurred: “Working in an intense B.A. Program. A violent teen kicked me repeatedly in each knees.” Lastly, and considerably, his doctor’s report on March 14, 2024 related the claimant’s prepatellar bursitis of each knees to this historical past: “kicked in each knees repeatedly by pupil.”
Thus the WCC agreed with the deputy commissioner that his bilateral knee harm is the results of cumulative trauma and subsequently not compensable underneath the employees compensation act.
The fee cited a case from 2007 that set forth the rule that to show an harm accidentally, the proof should show an identifiable incident; that happens at some moderately particular time; an apparent sudden mechanical or structural change within the physique; and a causal connection between the incident and bodily change.
In one other case, from 1985, an harm resulting from cumulative trauma was discovered not compensable as a result of it didn’t stem from a sudden identifiable incident or sudden occasion. In a 3rd, this from 1996, job-related impairments ensuing from “cumulative trauma brought on by repetitive movement, nevertheless labeled or nevertheless outlined, are, as a matter of legislation, not compensable underneath the current provisions of the Act.”
The college employee has the proper to attraction the choice to the Courtroom of Appeals of Virginia.
Matters
Workers’ Compensation
Talent
Virginia
K-12
Occupied with Ok 12?
Get automated alerts for this matter.
