Greater premiums and longer wait occasions make property homeowners much less happy with their insurers.
These not-very-surprising outcomes from J.D. Energy’s 2025 U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Study align with right this moment’s local weather of more and more longer declare cycle occasions and better prices for owners’ insurance coverage.
“Prospects are, in essence, paying greater costs for slower service,” mentioned Mark Garrett, director of insurance coverage intelligence at J.D. Energy. “The typical claimant doesn’t obtain closing cost on a declare till 44 days after the primary discover of loss, and until insurers talk regularly and clearly alongside the best way, buyer satisfaction suffers.”
General, the client satisfaction rating got here in at 682 (on a 1,000 level scale). Chubb ranks highest in property insurance coverage claims expertise with a rating of 773. Amica (745) ranks second and The Hartford (725) ranks third.
Influence of longer waits, greater premiums
The typical declare cycle time from submitting the declare to completed repairs is now 32.4 days, and the common cycle time from first discover of loss to closing cost is now greater than 44 days, the longest time since 2008. Claims accomplished inside 10 days rating 762 (on a 1,000-point scale), whereas repairs taking greater than 31 days rating 595.
Half the shoppers surveyed skilled insurer-initiated premium will increase prior to now 12 months. General satisfaction scores are 101 factors decrease (629 vs. 730) when insurers provoke a premium improve unrelated to having a declare than those that didn’t expertise a premium improve.
“There have been 27 catastrophic occasions in 2024 and 28 the 12 months earlier than,” Garrett mentioned. “Owners insurers are at the moment dropping roughly one nickel on each greenback of premium they accumulate, and with complete price of occasions just like the California wildfires nonetheless being assessed, there appears to be no finish in sight.”
How can insurers enhance satisfaction scores?
Communication might be key to mitigating insureds’ aggravation, JD Energy mentioned. General satisfaction scores are greater than twice as excessive (777) when prospects say it is rather simple to speak with their insurer than when it is rather tough or considerably tough to speak (337). Frequent failure factors embody typically needing to depart voicemails, needing to name with questions repeatedly, and never receiving well timed follow-up emails and textual content messages.
General satisfaction can be greater amongst prospects who use digital instruments when submitting a declare, submitting pictures which are used within the estimate and receiving proactive updates. Amongst digital channels, app utilization leads to the best ranges of satisfaction. Eighty-seven p.c of Gen Z and Millennials point out they’re snug managing your entire claims course of digitally. Solely 60% of Boomers and Pre-Boomers say they’re snug managing claims on-line.
Research parameters
The U.S. Property Claims Satisfaction Research was redesigned for 2025, so scores usually are not comparable with previous-year research. The research measures satisfaction with the property claims expertise amongst 5,178 home-owner insurance coverage prospects who filed a declare inside the earlier 9 months. The research was fielded from January 2024 via December 2024.
All for Carriers?
Get computerized alerts for this subject.
