ATLANTA (AP) — After years of stalled efforts to restrict civil lawsuits, Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp and Republican lawmakers are doubling down with a brand new push.
Supporters, most prominently business groups, name the state a “judicial hellhole,” and argue that companies are being crushed by rising insurance coverage prices pushed by extreme lawsuits which have helped plaintiffs get huge payouts.
“This subject shouldn’t be about enterprise,” stated Senate Majority Chief Steve Gooch, a Dahlonega Republican. “It’s about each Georgian paying increasingly premiums for his or her insurance coverage. No matter we are able to do to make it extra reasonably priced to personal a house, function your automobile and shield your loved ones with insurance coverage, we have to do it.”
However opponents say there’s no proof that lawsuits are intently linked to rising insurance coverage charges and that limits will make it tougher for injured events to win justice in courtroom.
“That is about attempting to do some favors for individuals who hopefully will line your political pockets,” stated Jen Jordan, an lawyer and former Democratic state senator. “On the finish of the day, Georgians are going to be harm.”
Kemp in 2023 promised the Georgia Chamber of Commerce, one among his high allies, that he would search to restrict lawsuit prices, a push that many name “tort reform.” However he admitted in 2024 that the hassle was sophisticated, and as an alternative signed a legislation to collect information on lawsuit verdicts.
At the same time as Kemp held occasions to construct public help forward of the legislative session, which begins Monday, the Republican governor is having to cope with GOP legal professionals within the Basic Meeting who make a dwelling by submitting lawsuits, Democrats who largely oppose adjustments, and a state Supreme Court docket that has voided earlier limits.
One key subject is lawsuits towards shops, condominium complexes and different companies over crimes or accidents on their property. In a single such lawsuit, Georgia mom Sheila Brooks sued Household Greenback and Greenback Tree final yr after her son Lem Johnny Johnson IV was fatally shot at one among their south Atlanta shops.
Police say the shooter wasn’t a Household Greenback worker, however the lawsuit alleges that Household Greenback knew about earlier incidents “involving gunshots, gunplay, assault, violent threats with weapons, and disturbing acts of violence” at and close to the placement. The shop ought to have taken extra safety measures to guard their clients, the criticism stated.
Supporters of lawsuit limits say property homeowners shouldn’t be held chargeable for the wrongdoing of shoppers and trespassers.
“If we repair this drawback, Georgia might be a a lot simpler, well-perceived place for companies and their insurers,” stated lawyer Invoice Custer. “It’s going to repair our fame as a bad-boy state.”
Nancy Palmer, a spokesperson for the Georgia Chamber of Commerce, stated Georgia’s authorized panorama has pushed insurance coverage firms out, making it tough for companies to get ample protection. She stated insurance coverage prices have develop into “untenable” throughout industries, affecting day care facilities, grocery retailer homeowners, pharmacies, low-income housing suppliers and others in city and rural areas alike.
Darion Dunn, a managing associate at Atlantica Properties, which develops affordable housing and is behind a micro neighborhood for beforehand unsheltered individuals generally known as “The Melody,” stated insurance coverage firms are elevating premiums or denying protection in areas they label as “excessive crime” resulting from considerations about litigation.
“Due to these rising insurance coverage prices, we’ve needed to stroll away from tasks that might in any other case have introduced much-needed reasonably priced housing,” Dunn stated.
Dunn needs to see lawmakers restrict the quantity of compensation individuals can look for non-economic damages corresponding to emotional ache and struggling. Georgia’s legislature capped such verdicts in 2005, however the state Supreme Court docket overturned the legislation in 2010 as unconstitutional.
Related: Insurers Taking Note of Big Verdicts But Trial Lawyers Don’t Expect Changes
The Georgia Trial Attorneys Affiliation disputes the concept insurance coverage prices are rising due to jury verdicts, and stated in a press release that “insurance coverage firms have continued to boost premiums regardless of making file income.”
To restrict a property proprietor’s legal responsibility, lawmakers may restrict the type of proof legal professionals can use to show property homeowners knew concerning the threat of incidents like Johnson’s killing.
Lawmakers may additionally instruct juries to assign a minimal quantity of blame to the one that dedicated the crime. In an oft-cited 2023 case, a person was awarded virtually $43 million in a lawsuit towards CVS after he was shot in a CVS car parking zone throughout an armed theft. The jury discovered CVS 95% chargeable for the capturing, the sufferer 5% accountable and assigned no accountability to the shooter.
These varieties of enormous verdicts are uncommon, stated Madeline Summerville, an Atlanta lawyer and political guide for Democrats. She stated giant verdicts usually consequence when insurers refuse to settle circumstances they need to, and whereas some circumstances are “frivolous,” most aren’t.
“You possibly can’t make laws primarily based on the truth that there’s a minority of oldsters which are attempting to sport the system after which persuade the entire individuals of Georgia that that’s nearly all of the circumstances which are coming by way of,” Summerville stated.
Summerville is especially apprehensive about adjustments to medical malpractice lawsuits, the place individuals sue medical suppliers for botched work. If medical practitioners aren’t held accountable, the extent of care will decline, she stated.
In a roundtable hosted by Kemp final fall, medical executives stated insurance coverage prices are rising and medical doctors worry working in Georgia as a result of they could get sued. Van Loskoski, CEO of Stephens County Hospital in Toccoa, stated the hospital couldn’t recruit obstetricians due to the worry of lawsuits and stopped delivering infants in 2021. The hospital’s medical malpractice premiums then fell by 13%, Loskoski stated.
Lawmakers additionally may take into account different measures, together with some much like legal guidelines handed in Florida in 2023. For instance, they may require attorneys to indicate jurors how a lot plaintiffs truly paid in medical payments, versus “phantom damages” primarily based on the quantities they have been initially charged. Legislators may additionally order separate trials to find out who’s at fault for medical damages and what these damages are.
Photograph: Darion Dunn, managing associate at Atlantica Properties, at The Melody fast housing growth in Atlanta. (AP Photograph/Charlotte Kramon)
Creator Charlotte Kramon is a corps member for The Related Press/Report for America Statehouse Information Initiative. Report for America is a nonprofit nationwide service program that locations journalists in native newsrooms to report on undercovered points. Comply with Kramon on X: @charlottekramon.
Copyright 2025 Related Press. All rights reserved. This materials will not be revealed, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Subjects
Legislation
Georgia
