A federal court docket on Wednesday affirmed a federal choose’s 2021 ruling imposing a $14.25 million penalty on Exxon Mobil for 1000’s of violations of the federal Clear Air Act on the firm’s refinery and chemical plant complicated in Baytown.
The choice by a majority of the Fifth Circuit Courtroom of Appeals rejects Exxon’s newest enchantment, closing over a decade of litigation because the Sierra Membership and Setting Texas sued the corporate in 2010.
“This ruling affirms a bedrock precept of constitutional legislation that individuals who reside close to pollution-spewing industrial services have a private stake in holding polluters accountable for non-compliance with federal air air pollution limits, and subsequently have a proper to sue to implement the Clear Air Act as Congress supposed,” Josh Kratka, managing legal professional on the Nationwide Environmental Legislation Heart and a lead lawyer on the case, stated in an announcement.
From 2005 to 2013, a federal choose present in 2017, Exxon’s refinery and chemical vegetation in Baytown launched 10 million kilos of air pollution past its state-issued air permits, together with carcinogenic and poisonous chemical substances. U.S. District Decide David Hittner ordered Exxon to pay $19.95 million as punishment for exceeding air air pollution limits on 16,386 days.
“We’re upset on this choice and contemplating different authorized choices,” an Exxon spokesperson stated in response to the ruling.
Baytown sits 25 miles exterior of Houston, with tens of 1000’s of individuals residing close to Exxon’s facility.
Exxon appealed and requested Hittner to re-examine how the superb was calculated, together with by contemplating how a lot cash the corporate saved by delaying repairs that might’ve prevented the surplus air emissions within the first place. The corporate additionally argued that it had introduced ample proof to point out that emissions had been unavoidable.
In 2021, Hittner decreased the superb to $14.25 million — the most important penalty imposed by a court docket out of a citizen-initiated lawsuit underneath the Clear Air Act, in line with Setting Texas. Exxon appealed once more, difficult the plaintiffs’ standing to deliver the lawsuit.
Whereas a majority of the Fifth Circuit Courtroom of Appeals affirmed Hittner’s 2021 choice on Wednesday, seven members of the 17-judge panel additionally stated they’d have upheld the $19.95 million superb.
“The principal problem earlier than the en banc Courtroom is whether or not Plaintiffs’ members, who reside, work, and recreate close to Exxon’s facility, have a ample ‘private stake’ in curbing Exxon’s ongoing and future illegal emissions of hazardous pollution,” the judges wrote in a concurring opinion. “We conclude that the district court docket accurately held that Plaintiffs established standing for every of their claims and didn’t abuse its discretion in awarding a penalty of $19.95 million in opposition to Exxon to discourage it from committing future violations.”
The Sierra Membership and Setting Texas sued Exxon underneath a provision within the federal Clear Air Act that enables residents to sue amid inaction by state and federal environmental regulators. The Texas Fee on Environmental High quality hardly ever penalizes corporations for unauthorized air emissions, a Texas Tribune investigation discovered.
“Folks in Baytown and Houston count on business to be good neighbors,” Luke Metzger, government director of Setting Texas, stated in an announcement. “However when corporations violate the legislation and put health-threatening air pollution into neighborhoods, they have to be held accountable.”
Disclosure: Exxon Mobil Company has been a monetary supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partially by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no position within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full listing of them right here.
This text initially appeared in The Texas Tribune at https://www.texastribune.org/2024/12/11/texas-exxon-clean-air-act-penalty-affirmed/.
The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and interesting Texans on state politics and coverage. Study extra at texastribune.org.
Considering Air pollution?
Get computerized alerts for this matter.
