Neither Artwork nor Renee Schaap might bear to remain on their dairy farm in Curry County, New Mexico, in April 2022 as staff put down the final of their cattle, taking pictures 1,000 within the head one after the other with .22 caliber bullets.
Staff dumped the carcasses right into a 20-foot-deep trench the size of a soccer discipline, creating two layers of rotting corpses that emanated a “odor of dying,” Renee mentioned. The soil is riddled with the toxins that killed them.
The herd — as soon as numbering 3,600 — had slowly been dying for years after consuming water contaminated by per- or polyfluoroalkyl substances, referred to as PFAS, from neighboring Cannon Air Drive Base.
The animals grew to become nugatory in 2018 when exams discovered ranges of the so-called without end chemical substances within the farm’s wells that have been as much as 23 occasions larger than the federal consuming water well being advisory on the time. Over a two-year interval, the Schaaps dumped as much as 18,000 gallons of milk a day that couldn’t be bought.
Farmers within the space tried to work with the Air Drive to scrub up the pollution however have been shocked in 2019 when the bottom sued New Mexico, saying officers didn’t have the authority to order a cleanup — a authorized battle that continues. In the meantime, a separate battle over Cannon’s culpability has turn into a bellwether case in nationwide litigation over whether or not the federal authorities is responsible for the contamination.
A important listening to is about for Feb. 7 earlier than the US District Court docket of South Carolina, which is managing hundreds of lawsuits claiming property, private harm and different injury from the froth referred to as AFFF. The US authorities has made three associated requests to dismiss all claims.
At the very least 27 companies, cities, counties, people and states have filed claims in opposition to the Air Drive, Military or Navy underneath a regulation referred to as the Federal Tort Claims Act, which describes when the federal government could be sued.
Extra claims have been filed underneath the Complete Environmental Response, Compensation and Legal responsibility Act, the regulation popularly referred to as Superfund, which might pressure a federal company to pay again prices expended for cleansing up hazardous substances from extremely polluted websites — on this case both of two particular PFAS the navy launched. Greater than 580 lively navy installations want nearer investigations as doable Superfund websites, the Pentagon discovered final 12 months.
If District Choose Richard M. Gergel sides with the federal government, the Pentagon is off the hook. If he doesn’t settle for the entire authorities’s arguments, litigation for some or all claims would proceed.
The stakes in Curry County are excessive for farmers whose livelihoods are in danger. Just a few miles previous the Schaaps’ Highland Dairy sits Southwest Cheese LLC the place greater than 5 billion kilos of milk is processed into cheese yearly and shipped everywhere in the globe. Its presence underscores agriculture’s dominant position within the space — and the potential influence on farmers and the regional economic system if the water contamination isn’t stopped.
The plant has been testing all incoming water for PFAS since 2019, and to date, none has been detected. However locals are involved in regards to the contamination spreading.Even the area’s sole consuming water supply — the Ogallala Aquifer — is in danger.
In the meantime, Cannon continues to be contributing to the issue.Final month, New Mexico’s Setting Division ordered Cannon to right away deal with and pay a tremendous for releasing 7,300 gallons of the firefighting foam final 12 months.
Kevin Ferrara, a retired Air Drive firefighter who served at Cannon from 1991 to 1995, says each 24-hour shift began with discharging foam throughout the airfield, the coaching areas and runways. It could in the end get washed right into a stormwater drain or the soil.
“We have been instructed it was like cleaning soap and water,” Ferrara mentioned. “I believed it was tremendous till after I acquired out and began doing my very own analysis.”
What he’s since discovered, partly from previous research the Division of Protection performed, frustrates Ferrara, an emergency service marketing consultant who now advocates for firefighter’s well being and security. “They’ve had many years to do the correct factor,” he mentioned.
Research have uncovered some clear warnings about AFFF, although there’s additionally some uncertainty about different dangers. In April 1978, for instance, the Naval Amenities Engineering Command highlighted environmental toxicities from AFFF. The memo advisable that the Navy develop toxicity tips and efficient therapy for the waste in addition to analysis safer types of fireplace suppressants made with different chemical substances.
The Air Drive has made efforts to mitigate PFAS contamination. As of final August, all AFFF was faraway from automobiles on the 3,789-acre base and close by 70,000-acre Melrose, a spokesperson mentioned. PFAS-containing merchandise and residuals have been collected and saved in a managed holding space whereas awaiting authorized disposal, it mentioned.
Cannon has additionally supplied water filters for 3 properties the place PFAS contamination exceeded the advisory degree set in 2016 by the Environmental Safety Company, a base official mentioned. The EPA doesn’t regulate effectively water, however final 12 months it restricted the quantity of two PFAS in public consuming water programs: perfluorooctanoic acid and perfluorooctane sulfonate.
The bottom can be constructing a $73 million groundwater therapy plant that’s scheduled to begin working in March. The startup has been delayed as a result of among the electrical elements wanted have been on order for greater than a 12 months, mentioned Christipher Gierke, who oversees environmental restoration efforts at Cannon. The system will ultimately have the ability to deal with 86,000 gallons a day, he mentioned.
However there are obstacles. Amongst them are the dearth of authorized applied sciences to destroy PFAS, mentioned Brian Howard, a senior technical advisor for the Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Air Drive for Setting, Security and Infrastructure. Congress has barred the Protection Division from incinerating PFAS-containing waste till it could possibly meet standards that reveals full destruction, which continues to be in improvement.
One other problem has been the EPA’s regular revision of standards used to find out how contaminated websites are. So-called screening ranges are utilized by federal companies, states and firms to look at websites and decide whether or not chemical concentrations are excessive sufficient to trigger issues.
Every change meant the Air Drive’s contractors needed to reexamine bases to find out if the newly added types of PFAS have been current and if the older ones exceeded the revised, decrease normal. In 2016, the EPA had set ranges for 3 varieties of PFAS. Now there are more than a dozen.
Dairy farms liable to contamination have begun filtering water on their very own as they attempt to preserve their companies going, however it’s costly and time-consuming, consuming into income and earnings.
And farmers rising crops, together with ones that lease land for cattle to graze, are apprehensive in regards to the influence the toxins could have on their property values, based on Republican state Senator Pat Woods, a rancher whose great- great-grandfather got here to New Mexico as a homesteader. “There’s quite a lot of resentment. You’re employed your complete life to pay to your place,” Woods mentioned. And now “land worth is fairly shaky.”
However whether or not native companies can claw again the money spent making an attempt to mitigate the issues themselves stays to be seen.
If the courtroom decides the federal government could be sued underneath the Federal Tort Claims Act for alleged harms finished because it used and launched AFFF, that will open the door to sooner cleanups and injury compensation, mentioned Ken Sansone, a senior accomplice with SL Environmental Regulation Group PC.
However one of many authorities’s key arguments to dismiss the Schaap’s and associated lawsuits is that companies’ use of AFFF qualifies for what’s referred to as the discretionary operate exception underneath that regulation. There have been no insurance policies or laws utilized to AFFF for a lot of the many years it was used, so the federal government maintains that it’s not responsible for its discretionary use of the firefighting foam.
The discretionary operate exception “is the most important hurdle to restoration of tort claims,” mentioned John McGahren, deputy chair of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP’s world environmental observe, which isn’t concerned within the multidistrict litigation.
A second key argument the federal government makes is that the technique, time and method it makes use of to scrub up contaminated websites can’t be challenged underneath CERCLA.
But barring states from difficult the size, scope or different features of federal Superfund PFAS investigations and cleanups can be “like letting the fox guard the henhouse,” mentioned James Kenney, secretary of the New Mexico Setting Division.
“If you happen to’re permitting the polluter to find out how the cleanup and the notification is finished, you’re sure to run into some issues,” mentioned Zachary Ogaz, common counsel for the division. “It’s important that the state has the authority to control all these releases and all these services, as a result of we are able to’t anticipate them to carry themselves accountable.”
Some residents and companies selected to not anticipate a verdict to take motion. Vance Dewbre, who has a five-acre property close to the Schaaps, says he put in a filter for his house at a value of about $2,000, not counting the annual filter replacements that value $400.
“You refill your faucet and surprise if it’s secure to drink,” he mentioned. “That’s one thing that 99.9% of individuals don’t have to consider. They realize it’s secure. Not us.”
However not everybody can afford that, so the New Mexico Setting Division has requested the legislature for $4 million to supply public water to Curry County residents.
For now, the ditch on the Schaap’s land is stuffed with contaminated cow carcasses. They’ve solely averted chapter as a result of they personal two smaller dairies away from Cannon’s air pollution. “We simply wish to transfer on and have a traditional life once more,” Artwork Schaap mentioned.
It weighs on Ferrara’s thoughts. Theformer Air Drive firefighter remembers the Schaap’s farm being simply on the opposite aspect of the fence surrounding Cannon’s perimeter. “And it’s not simply what occurred at Cannon. It’s across the nation,” he mentioned.
“The chain hyperlink fence didn’t maintain issues again. It acquired off the bottom and that impacts harmless individuals. The navy has a duty to behave in a approach that holds itself accountable for that.”
Photograph: Cow bone fragments floor to the highest of a now-covered PFAS containment trench. Photographer: Pat Rizzuto/Bloomberg.
Copyright 2025 Bloomberg.
Subjects
Agribusiness
