Exxon Mobil Corp. filed a lawsuit alleging that California Legal professional Common Rob Bonta and several other environmental teams made defamatory feedback concerning the oil firm’s potential to recycle plastic.
Exxon accused Bonta, the Sierra Group and others of creating “false accusations” about its superior recycling course of. Exxon mentioned in a go well with filed in federal courtroom in Texas Monday that the method works and the claims have broken its relationship with clients.
Rob Bonta, lawyer normal of California, throughout an interview in San Francisco, California, US, on Thursday, March 7, 2024. Bonta final month in an interview mentioned the state was in contact with the US Justice Division concerning the potential Apple Inc. antitrust case and will be a part of onto an eventual criticism. Photographer: Loren Elliott/Bloomberg
“With apparently no appreciation for the irony of their declare, Mr. Bonta and his cohorts are actually partaking in reverse greenwashing,” in response to the criticism. “Whereas posing beneath the banner of environmentalism, they do harm to real recycling packages and to significant innovation.”
Bonta, a Democrat, sued Exxon on behalf of California in September over claims of public nuisance, water air pollution and deceptive environmental advertising and marketing. In an announcement on the time, Bonta alleged the corporate “falsely promoted all plastic as recyclable” when in actual fact the US recycling price has by no means exceeded 9%. Exxon and different producers are additionally going through plastics recycling fits by a Kansas county and by residents in 4 states.
In current months, Exxon has proven a willingness to make use of the courts to defend its fame and authorized rights when attacked by critics, particularly these centered on the setting. Final yr, the corporate sued two of its personal buyers to take away environmental proposals from the poll at its annual assembly.
Exxon sought to proceed the go well with even after the proposals had been withdrawn, claiming to be a “forceful advocate” for shareholder rights, however the case was finally dismissed.
The corporate claims Bonta made the anti-Exxon statements in a “deliberate smear marketing campaign” in his “private capability to drive up donations and publicity for his political marketing campaign.” It additionally accuses one of many defendants, the Intergenerational Atmosphere Justice Fund Ltd., of serving “personal overseas pursuits” via its relationship with Perth-based Fortescue Metals Group Ltd.
Bonta’s workplace mentioned the go well with is “one other try from Exxon Mobil to deflect consideration from its personal illegal deception” and that the lawyer normal “appears to be like ahead to vigorously litigating this case in courtroom.”
In its personal assertion, the the Australia-registered non-profit group Intergenerational Atmosphere Justice Fund mentioned it’s not managed by Fortescue and its actions in California had been to “take motion on the difficulty of plastic waste.”
Fortescue, which isn’t named as a defendant, rejected Exxon’s assertions within the go well with, together with the declare it orchestrated litigation to realize a aggressive benefit within the low-carbon vitality house. The Australian miner is “absolutely dedicated” to inexperienced hydrogen, a spokesman mentioned in an announcement.
The Sierra Membership mentioned the go well with is “a shameless try at intimidation by a multibillion greenback polluter company that coated up its local weather change denial for many years.”
The Sierra Membership has obtained funding from Bloomberg Philanthropies, the charitable group based by Michael Bloomberg, who is almost all proprietor of Bloomberg Information mum or dad Bloomberg LP.
The case is Exxon Mobil Company v. Bonta, 25-cv-00011, US District Courtroom, Jap District of Texas (Beaumont).
Prime picture: Rob Bonta, lawyer normal of California, throughout an interview in San Francisco, California, on Thursday, March 7, 2024. Photographer: Loren Elliott/Bloomberg
Copyright 2025 Bloomberg.
Matters
Lawsuits
California
Pollution
Enthusiastic about Lawsuits?
Get computerized alerts for this subject.
